Immigration Reform Under Trump’s Administration: A Focus on Arizona
President Donald Trump has made immigration reform a cornerstone of his agenda during his initial 100 days in office, particularly influencing policies that resonate deeply within communities in Arizona. With sweeping changes to longstanding programs, the ramifications for immigrants and their families are significant and far-reaching.
Understanding Rapid Policy Changes
Angela Banks, an immigration law professor at Arizona State University, expressed concern regarding the swift pace of these changes. “It’s sort of hard for people to keep up and know exactly what their rights are or what the situation is right now,” she noted. The Trump administration’s alterations to immigration policy have predominantly aimed at decreasing overall immigration and limiting pathways for many who seek to enter or remain in the U.S.
Major Shifts in Immigration Policy
Banks outlined three critical areas where Trump’s policies could create considerable effects:
-
Access to Birthright Citizenship: Trump signed an executive order that seeks to modify the principles of birthright citizenship. This order posits that children born to unlawfully present mothers, or fathers who are neither U.S. citizens nor lawful permanent residents, would be denied citizenship. Moreover, the citizenship of children with parents holding temporary statuses may also be affected. Notably, this executive order is currently facing judicial challenges and has yet to be enforced.
-
Increased Deportations: The Trump administration has invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to facilitate deportations of specific groups, including members of the Venezuelan gang Tren De Agua. Over 250 Venezuelan nationals were deported before a court intervened to halt further actions under this initiative, which is also being contested in court. The trend highlights a broader shift toward expedited removals without the traditional judicial oversight.
- Changes to Asylum Procedures: Trump’s approach has led to significant transformations in how asylum requests are processed. Key changes include the revision of the CBP One app into a self-deportation tool, known as CBP Home, and a suspension of humanitarian parole initiatives. Such measures reflect a stark departure from previous practices, complicating access for those seeking refuge in the U.S.
Perspectives from Local Republicans
Local Republican leaders in Maricopa County have described Trump’s first 100 days as "shockingly successful." Craig Berland, chairman of the county Republican Party, commended the administration’s strategy for encouraging self-deportation among undocumented individuals. His assertion emphasizes a zero-tolerance stance against those failing to comply with U.S. immigration laws.
Shelby Busch, also from the county’s Republican faction, expressed a sense of security stemming from the administration’s policies. She likened the border crisis to a broken pipe, advocating for drastic measures to resolve the situation before implementing a streamlined pathway for immigrants wishing to assimilate.
Voices from the Community
The impact of these policies is palpably felt among immigrant communities. Jose Patiño, a DACA recipient and an advocate for mixed-immigration-status families through the organization Aliento, highlighted feelings of betrayal among individuals who believed they had followed the proper channels for immigration. “We did it the right way, right?” he recounted, reflecting the confusion and disillusionment faced by many.
Despite a lack of large-scale immigration enforcement raids, targeted operations have left immigrant families feeling vulnerable. Patiño noted a notable shift in public perception among these communities, exacerbated by fear that has infiltrated daily life. “Some families are afraid to send their kids to school, go to church on Sundays, or even seek medical care,” he explained.
As Arizona grapples with the implications of these policy shifts, the dialogue surrounding immigration continues to evolve, marked by deep divides and varying perspectives on the future of immigration in America. The ongoing legal challenges and community responses will undoubtedly shape the narrative in the months to come.
